Trick-or-Treated by Three Silver Foxes – Nicole Casey

3.5 stars

Where can I find a fairly anonymous website to fulfill all my secret wants? Now would be an excellent time for my phone to be secretly listening to me…..

I really enjoyed Margo as a character. She’s unapologetically herself and isn’t afraid to get back up when life knocks her down. I loved how real and genuine she was, and her friends are an absolute riot! I need a Sugarplum Gang in my life!

The men were fun characters also; each with their own past trauma and reasons for granting one of Margo’s wishes. I did like that they each struggled a little with the concept of sharing a woman instead of just immediately accepting and diving right in. The angst and competition makes for really fun relationship dynamics in the story.

Where this fell a little short though, was the wishes themselves. For something advertised as being able to grant your dirtiest fantasies, I was expecting a five alarm fire. However, Margo’s wishes were more toward the emotionally healing side with a touch of spice. Not to knock emotional healing, far from it, but I had a different expectation for how that aspect of the story would be so I couldn’t help but be a little disappointed.

I will say that I now have the biggest vendetta against the word ‘plump’ and hope I never see it again as long as I live in reference to a male’s equipment……